The Good brew

Kombucha vs. Soft Drinks: The Real Difference in Sugar and Gut Impact

The Good Brew Company | Kombucha vs. Soft Drinks: The Real Difference in Sugar and Gut Impact
The Environmental Impact of Kombucha - Eco-Friendly Drinks
Is kombucha just another fizzy drink dressed up in health claims? Or is it truly different from soft drinks like Coke and lemonade?

If you’ve found yourself comparing labels or wondering what the real difference is, you’re not alone.

This guide breaks down three key areas – sugar content, fermentation process, and gut health impact to help you decide which drink actually serves your body (and which one just satisfies your sweet tooth).

Sugar Levels: A Clear Comparison

Here’s a side-by-side comparison:

Drink Sugar per 100ml Sugar per Standard Serve (375ml can)
Coca-Cola Classic 10.6g ~40g
Lemonade (typical brand) 10.5g ~39g
Raw Kombucha (Good Brew) ~2.5g ~9g
Filtered Commercial Kombucha 4–6g ~15–22g

Unlike soft drinks, where all sugar is added after production, kombucha’s sugar is used during fermentation. The SCOBY (symbiotic culture of bacteria and yeast) converts sugar into organic acids and natural carbonation – meaning the final sugar content is much lower than what’s added at the start.

Residual sugar (kombucha) is what remains after fermentation. Added sugar (soft drinks) is dumped in for taste – and stays in full.

Learn more about how our kombucha is brewed and bottle-conditioned.

Fermentation vs. Flavouring

Here’s the core difference in how these drinks are made:

Soft Drinks:

Made with carbonated water, added sugars, flavours, and preservatives

Artificially fizzy via injected CO₂

Contains no living organisms or functional ingredients

Kombucha:

Brewed from tea, sugar, and a live SCOBY

Fermented over days or weeks

Naturally fizzy, rich in organic acids, and often contains live cultures (if unpasteurised)

The result? A drink with depth, complexity, and natural acidity — not just sweetness.

Find out what makes kombucha fermentation so unique.

Kombucha Scoby Glass Container - Good Brew
Kombucha Jar | Fermentation Jar

Gut Health: One Helps, One Hurts

Soft Drinks:

While they might taste great going down, soft drinks are high in added sugars and offer zero benefit to your gut. In fact, excessive intake of sugary sodas has been linked to reduced microbiome diversity and increased inflammation in the gut.

Kombucha:

When it’s raw and unpasteurised (like our Good Brew range), kombucha contains a living mix of beneficial microbes — including acetic acid bacteria, yeasts, and lactic acid bacteria.

These cultures can:

Help balance your gut flora

Support digestion

Offer gentle antimicrobial effects

No, it’s not a miracle cure. But it’s a living beverage with more in common with yoghurt than lemonade.

See what the RMIT study found in our kombucha microbiome breakdown.

Energy & Crash Factor

That 3pm Coke might feel refreshing, but what happens next?

Effect Soft Drink Kombucha
Initial energy boost High (due to sugar hit) Mild (gradual release via organic acids)
Crash afterwards Likely (insulin spike + drop) Unlikely (no sugar spike)
Lasting hydration Low (high sugar = dehydrating) Higher (lower sugar, fermented tea base)

Many people are now turning to kombucha as a functional beverage — something that satisfies the need for fizz and flavour, but without the metabolic rollercoaster.

Want more ideas on how to build kombucha into your daily rhythm?
Check out Why Kombucha Works Best as a Routine.

So, Is Kombucha Really Better Than Soft Drink?

In short: yes – when it’s real kombucha.

While both drinks might come in a bottle and sparkle when opened, kombucha is fundamentally different:

It’s fermented, not flavoured

It supports, rather than stresses, your gut

It contains less sugar and more function
But be aware: not all kombucha is created equal. Some supermarket brands are pasteurised, filtered, or sweetened to mimic soda — which defeats the point.

Use our guide to spot a real brew before you buy.

Kombucha Brewery In A Box - Good Brew
Kombucha Complete 6 Pack - Good Brew

Taste the Difference for Yourself

You don’t have to give up fizz — just give up the dead sugar water.
Good Brew kombucha is:

Raw and alive with over 200 microbial strains

Brewed the traditional way

Naturally low in sugar

100% Australian-made and cold-kept

Shop the Good Brew range and try a real alternative to soft drinks — your gut will thank you.